Just because I know you're probably doing some sort of school project on this:
I can't decide, just yet. It calls upon the entire "temporary insanity" excitement. I suppose the only way you can really draw the line is with something subjective, like the DSM. It's the only preexisting diagnostic tool fit to handle this kind of conversation. Otherwise, you're going to encounter issues regarding various levels of psychosis or whatever you'd want to call it.
Take serial killers. We've proven that their brains function differently, so how can we determine that someone experiencing temporary insanity or someone suffering from DID is not liable for their actions and someone with an anatomically different brain be held accountable for killing? That's where the DSM comes in handy with a definitive yes-no in regards to whether something is classified as a syndrome.
Unfortunately, the primary use of the DSM is insurance, which is really not a comparable paradigm. So, hell, let 'em off the hook. Put 'em in treatment (because they probably should be). If the argument against holding them accountable (presumably, jailing) is that it's unethical, because they can't control themselves, that doesn't mean it's unethical to hospitalize them or something. It's protective, it's beneficial, and it's more ethical. Hopefully.
But hey, what do I know?
Showing posts with label Psychology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Psychology. Show all posts
Tuesday, October 26, 2010
Q&A #1
Posted by
Brent
at
5:26 PM
Just looking for some opinion:
Should individuals with DID (Dissociative Identity Disorder) be held criminal responsible for their crimes?
And...go!
Labels:
Psychology,
Q
Sunday, October 17, 2010
Lost in the Week.
Posted by
Andy
at
11:38 PM
Something I discovered today:
Bon Iver. Honestly, I'm a little shocked at how far behind I am on this one. Anyway, I'm hoping at least a few of you are even further behind on it than I am. It's nice to have a bit of a break from my current trend of music. I threw up four songs that I've been listening to a lot, recently. I've got to admit that my interest in Bon Iver was perked by Kanye West.
So much for getting away from what I usually listen to. But guys, really, I'll try and avoid just posting a metric shit ton of hip hop or rap or whatever it is you guys think I listen to. Because neither of us want that. Neither. Uh.
Oh man. This is gonna be tough.
I've started working in a psych lab just this past week, doing social psychology experiments. Haven't got a chance to run any, just yet, but we're in the prep stage. It should be pretty interesting, tampering with the door-in-the-face technique that a lot of you have probably learned about. Feel free to ask if you've never heard of it/can't remember. Considering I should probably learn to explain it in my sleep, now.
And that's cool and all, but it's really brought to light the fact that I need to start making decisions about my life that I've been putting off for the last few months. Well, years. Specifically (in this conversation), it's my running debate of pursuing clinical psychology or branching off into the social psychology sphere. I've essentially been telling myself that I'll keep pursuing what I consider to be the harder one of the two, and the one I prefer, until I realize that it's no longer attainable. That is, I'll keep working to become a legitimate clinical psychologist until someone says that I'm not qualified. Then I'll switch to social psychology and perhaps a run at marketing, or even law.
Really, I just think I'd look good in a suit.
The problem I'm facing is that until someone actually says those words ("Andy, you don't have what it takes."), I'll never know when it's time to call it a career. But this lab had got me thinking that I'd thrown in the towel, and decided that social psychology is the way to go. Then, as the ball in my brain started rolling, I realized that no, I wasn't ready to give up. So next semester, when my commitment to my lab is up, I'm going for a position in a clinical lab. I've also been looking into grad school, recently. I suppose, ever since I received an email about Ryerson's clinical psychology graduate program. Yeah. That'd do it.
I think I'm just afraid that if I postpone this decision too long, I'll find out that I'm chasing a pipe dream just a minute too late and both my plan and my backup plan will pass me by.
But I'm not going to let that stop me from taking the risk.
It's fall. Winter's just around the corner. How do you guys feel about that? Personally, I feel like this year's going a lot faster. I like that, but at the same time I feel like I should be a lot further ahead than I am. It's troubling.
Files:
Skinny Love - Bon Iver
The Wolves (Act I and II) - Bon Iver
Re: Stacks - Bon Iver
Blindsided - Bon Iver
Lost in the World - Kanye West ft. Bon Iver
here
Labels:
Bon Iver,
Fall,
Music,
Psychology
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)